Deciding between hardware and software encoding begins with grasping encoding fundamentals and their performance implications. This understanding is crucial, especially when aligning encoding choices with business objectives, available infrastructure, team skillsets, and cost considerations. Whether prioritizing speed, quality, efficiency, or flexibility, it's essential to tailor encoding strategies to desired business outcomes.
What is hardware encoding?
Hardware encoding is encoding your video files using specialized hardware systems. It is like hiring a professional packing service. They use specialized tools (like vacuum sealers and compression bags) and expertise to efficiently pack your belongings (video data) into compact suitcases (compressed video chunks) suitable for travel (streaming). They can handle a large volume of items (high-resolution content) quickly and flawlessly, even on a chaotic morning (busy LAN).
Advantages of hardware encoding
Faster and more efficient: Hardware encoders are typically much faster and more efficient than software encoders, resulting in higher-quality video and lower latency.
Less CPU/GPU usage: Hardware encoders offload the encoding process from the CPU and GPU, freeing up resources for other tasks. This can improve overall system performance and reduce the risk of overheating.
Better video quality: Hardware encoders can produce better video quality than software encoders, especially at high bitrates and with complex video content.
Lower latency: Hardware encoders can produce lower latency video than software encoders, which is important for live streaming applications.
Disadvantages of hardware encoding
Cost: Hardware encoders can be expensive, ranging from a few hundred dollars to several thousand depending on features and capabilities. This upfront cost might not be ideal for beginners or casual streamers.
Limited flexibility: Hardware encoders often have a more limited range of configuration options compared to software encoders. While they offer presets for various platforms, they might not allow for fine-tuning of specific settings.
Compatibility: Not all hardware encoders are compatible with every streaming platform or software. It's crucial to ensure compatibility before purchasing a hardware encoder.
Upgrades: Upgrading hardware encoders might be more challenging compared to software encoders. Newer encoding standards or features might require purchasing a completely new device, while software updates can often add new functionalities.
Portability: Hardware encoders are typically external devices that require additional cables and setup. This reduces portability compared to software encoders that run directly on your computer.
Learning curve: Hardware encoders might have a steeper learning curve compared to some software encoders, especially for those new to streaming technology.
When to use hardware encoders?
If you're an engineering manager or streaming engineer trying to decide whether to go for hardware encoding, here are some cases where it might be the best option:
Prioritizing stream quality and reliability:
Professional live streaming: For mission-critical streams where high video quality and smooth delivery are paramount (e.g., live events, webinars, professional broadcasts), hardware encoders offer dedicated processing power for consistent performance.
Multiple sources and complex setups: When your streams involve multiple cameras, graphics overlays, or other demanding elements, a hardware encoder can handle the encoding workload without compromising your computer's ability to run other tasks.
Lower-end machines: If your target audience uses computers that might not have powerful CPUs or GPUs for software encoding, a hardware encoder ensures smooth playback even on less-capable machines.
Maintaining system performance: For tasks where your computer's processing power is crucial (e.g., real-time editing, gaming), a hardware encoder frees up your CPU and GPU, preventing slowdowns during encoding.
Other Factors to Consider when choosing hardware encoders:
Team expertise: If your team has limited experience with setting up and managing software encoders would be easier, a hardware encoder might require more hand holding.
Budget: Hardware encoders can be an investment, so weigh the cost against the benefits for your specific needs.
What is software encoding?
Software encoding is a process of using software packages to compress and encode your video files using your device's processing power.
It is like you're packing your own bags (encoding the video). You try your best to fold and fit everything in (compress the video) using the tools at hand (your computer's CPU/GPU). While it can work for smaller trips (lower-resolution content), packing fragile or sophisticated objects (high-resolution video) might take longer and be less efficient, potentially leading to breakage or loss of quality (loss of video quality).
Advantages of software encoding
Cost-effectiveness: Software encoders are significantly cheaper than their hardware counterparts. Many popular options are free and open-source, like OBS Studio, making them ideal for beginners, casual streamers, or those on a budget.
Flexibility: Software encoders offer a wider range of configuration options. This allows for fine-tuning encoding settings to achieve the desired balance between quality, bitrate, and file size, catering to specific streaming platforms or needs.
Compatibility: Software encoders generally have broader compatibility with various streaming platforms and software. They often work seamlessly with your existing computer setup.
Upgrades and updates: Unlike hardware encoders, software encoders receive regular updates and can adapt to new encoding standards or features. This ensures your encoding remains relevant without needing to purchase a new device.
Portability: Software encoders are incredibly portable as they run directly on your computer. You can take your encoding setup anywhere, making it ideal for travel or on-location streaming.
Learning curve: Many software encoders are user-friendly and have intuitive interfaces, making them easier to learn for beginners compared to some hardware encoders.
Resource utilization: Modern software encoders can leverage hardware acceleration capabilities of your computer's GPU, offering improved performance compared to relying solely on the CPU.
Community support: Popular software encoders often have large and active communities, providing readily available resources, tutorials, and support in case you encounter any issues.
When should i use software encoding?
Software encoding shines in several scenarios, especially when dealing with less sophisticated media and starting a new streaming venture.
Imagine you're baking cookies for a small gathering. A simple oven (software encoder) is perfectly adequate to bake delicious cookies (encoded video) in a reasonable time (encoding process). However, if you need to open a bakery and produce large quantities of cookies (high-resolution, complex videos), a dedicated industrial oven (hardware encoder) might become necessary for efficiency.
Use Sofware Encoding for less sophisticated edia:
Lower resolution: Software encoding is perfectly capable of handling lower resolution videos, like 720p or even standard definition (SD). These videos require less processing power to encode, making software a viable and efficient option.
Simpler editing: If you're not doing complex video editing with multiple layers and effects, the encoding demands won't be as high. Software encoders can handle these basic encoding tasks effectively.
Limited bitrate needs: For lower bitrate requirements and for less sophisticated media. Software encoders can achieve good quality at these bitrates without stressing your computer's resources.
Starting new with lower streaming volume:
Budget-friendly: The cost-effectiveness of software encoders is a major advantage for beginners. Starting out, investing in a dedicated hardware encoder might be optional, especially with lower volume content creation.
Flexibility for experimentation: Software encoders offer a wide range of configuration options. This allows you to experiment and find the optimal settings for your specific content and platform without needing a new device.
Scalability as you grow: Software encoders can handle increased volume as your content creation grows. You can gradually upgrade your computer's hardware if needed to accommodate higher encoding demands in the future.
FastPix effortless encoding and video streaming for businesses
FastPix eliminates the complexity of video streaming for SMEs and Mid-market companies. Our intelligent APIs analyze your video content and automatically optimize compression for stunning quality at the lowest cost. Slash encoding costs by 30% while delivering flawless high-definition streaming on any device. This translates to proportionally lower streaming costs, maximizing your return on investment.
No more manual configuration or wasted resources.
Start Your Free Trial and Experience hassle-free streaming today!
FAQS on Software VS Hardware encoding
Should I use Hardware encoding Vs Software encodingn for live steaming?
Most software encoders can handle live streaming, performance issues may arise when dealing with a high number of concurrent streams or using multiple video sources. In these cases, hardware encoding is often preferred to ensure consistent quality and reduce the burden on your CPU.
Should I use hardware encoding or software encoding for broadcasting ?
In broadcasting, software encoders are a versatile toolkit for many tasks. However, like any general-purpose library, they can struggle with demanding scenarios like complex setups with multiple video sources. In these cases, hardware encoding becomes the specialized tool of choice. Hardware encoders deliver consistent broadcast quality and minimize CPU overhead on your machines, ensuring smooth operation under pressure.
Can you use GPU as a hardware encoder?
Yes, many modern GPUs (Graphics Processing Units) come with built-in hardware encoders that can be used for video encoding tasks. This is particularly useful for tasks like video streaming, video recording, and other applications that involve encoding video data.
In terms of speed, which encoding is better, software or hardware encoding?
In terms of speed, hardware encoding is much faster in encoding video file than software encoding.
In terms of bitrate efficiency, which encoding is better, software or hardware encoding ?
For the best bitrate efficiency (quality per bitrate), software encoding tends to be superior due to its flexibility and ability to use advanced encoding techniques. However, for scenarios where encoding speed and system resource usage are critical, hardware encoding might be preferred despite potentially lower bitrate efficiency. The ideal choice depends on the specific needs of the use case, such as real-time streaming (where hardware encoding might be preferred) versus offline video processing (where software encoding can be more effective).
In terms of video quality, which encoding is better, software or hardware encoding ?
Software encoding generally provides better video quality due to the use of more advanced algorithms and greater flexibility in encoding settings, however, the econding time might be long.
How does the choice between hardware and software encoding affect cloud costs for streaming?
There is a potential cost reduction with hardware encoding, but you have an initial purchase cost. While, for software encoding, though the initial costs are low, it might lead to higher storage and bandwidth cost Ultimately, the best approach depends on your specific needs and priorities. Consider the trade-off between upfront hardware cost and potential cloud cost savings when making your decision.
With OBS should I use hardware or software encoding?
Hardware encoding is usually recommended by engineers for OBS. As they take off load from CPU.
What is hardware accelerated encoding?
Hardware accelerated encoding is the process of using specialized hardware components to encode video data instead of relying solely on your computer's central processing unit (CPU).
What is Apple VT h264 hardware encoder?
Apple VT H.264 Hardware Encod built into Apple devices (Mac computers, iPhones, iPads) that leverages the device's dedicated hardware to encode videos using the H.264 codec.
What are some good encoder for live streaming?
OBS, WireCast, Tricaster are some best encoders for live streaming in the market.
What are the best hardware encoders available in the market?
Teradek Vidiu X, LiveU Solo,VidiU Go, Niagara Video, TriCaster are some of the best hardware encoders available in the market.
What are the best software encoders available in the market?
OBS Studio, Wirecast, VidBlasterX, vMix, XSplit Broadcaster are some of the best software encoders available in the market.
.png)
.png)
.png)
